Living—and
Dying—by Example
Proximity
to death is to be expected in certain professions
dedicated to protecting life such as law enforcement,
firefighting, and medicine, among others. Being
young and my immediate family being in good
health, I naively anticipated that I would become
acquainted with death through formal contact
with the patients I encountered in the hospital.
It turns out that while I was busy looking for
death in the distance, it quietly and nonchalantly
came to curl up next to me like a cat.
From
the time that my friend and classmate Neil Ghiso
was first diagnosed with a brain tumor in 1997
until his recent death in February of 2002,
chronic illness and death have been part of
everyday life for all who knew him. As a result,
witnessing Neil's journey over the past five
years has taught me about what it can mean for
patients and their families and friends to live
in intimate contact with a terminal illness.
I have been moved by Neil's courage and the
compassion of his family and friends in the
face of his illness. I was also moved by the
dignity and the sense of hope they created together,
especially as it became clear that surgery and
medication had no more to offer him. I think
of that experience as a gift, one that his family
and friends hope will live on through the formation
of a foundation in Neil's name. Care for the
Chronically and Terminally Ill
The
Neil Samuel Ghiso Foundation (NSGF) is "dedicated
to fostering compassionate care for chronically
and terminally ill patients and their families
through medical education and training."
Its pilot project aims to offer medical students
between their first and second years the opportunity
to investigate ways to enhance the care of this
patient population. Initially, students will
round with Dr. Robert Buxbaum, HMS assistant
professor of medicine at the Mariner Health
at Longwood hospice facility. Neil was one of
his patients. Students will focus on issues
such as improving the dialogue between patients
and providers and will be free to define hypotheses
of their own regarding the role of the physician
in circumstances that are emotionally difficult
for patients and families.
The
formation of the NSGF is not in response to
a failure in Neil's care. Instead it is a measure
of how successful Neil and his family were at
making the many difficult decisions they faced
after his diagnosis. First Neil had to decide
how to fight back, which he did with multiple
surgeries, chemotherapy, radiation, and drugs
to control his worsening seizures. His family
fought back by repeatedly flying out from Chicago
at a moment's notice, and his friends by dropping
what they were doing to accompany him to his
meetings with various doctors.
The
other decisions Neil had to make were harder
still: how to prepare for a life of chronic
illness and possibly early death. After his
diagnosis, Neil would have been justified in
quitting medical school and moving back home
with family. Instead he chose to stay the course
he had initially set for himself. In spite of
his illness, the seizures, the memory loss,
he graduated from medical school with honors
in 2001 and even gave one of the student speeches
at commencement the year before. As Neil's symptoms
made it progressively harder for him to go on
in medicine, he refused to withdraw from the
world and worked in a bookstore. All the while
he was affectionate and tender toward those
who loved him. Even as his symptoms were beginning
to overtake him, he placed the comfort of others
before his own. He never flinched when asked
about his symptoms. And at the end, he made
it easy for us to relate to him because we did
not need to waste a single minute pretending
that this wasn't happening. I believe this freed
all those involved to enjoy his company and
focus on his life. Instead of choosing how he
was going to die, Neil chose how he was going
to live.
"Healing
Without a Cure" The chronically and terminally
ill are at risk for having their choices severely
limited by more than their disease. Family pressure
to deal with illness in a manner not consistent
with the patient's priorities can alienate patients
from their own experience. To paraphrase a friend
of Neil's who spoke after his funeral, Neil's
family's acceptance of his wish to continue
to live in Boston and finish medical school
was a compassionate and healing gesture because
it made it possible for hope to persist. It
could be hope for some personal reconciliation,
hope for seeing a project come to fruition,
or just the hope of feeling intimately connected
to loved ones.
Doctors
who care only about cures have no way of communicating
alternative forms of hope to patients and close
off alternative paths to healing when they are
needed the most. The mission of the NSGF
is to promote the healing that is possible even
when there are no cures. The genesis of
the foundation is a testament to the hope and
creativity that are possible even in the face
of death.
-
Alex Carter,
MD-PhD
|